May 2, 2008
The pride of modern Calvinism, the humililty of Puritanism
Who were Puritans?
Many Christians today still love and read the vast volumes written by the Puritans. Many people today will use the term Puritan about themselves; yet often, when looking at their beliefs, their lives, their values, and last, but by no means least, the way they do or don’t apply Scripture to their lives day-to-day, or where it is on their richter scale of priorities, they have no claim to the name Puritan, and by the examples they give in the ways above, seen very ignorant or unlearned of exactly who or what the Puritans were for them to even take the name to themselves, it is one of my pet peeves, or treading on my blue Suede shoes, when this lack of knowledge about exactly who the Puritans were while claiming the name to themselves, often does more to harm and damage to the reputation of the Puritans, which cost many of them their lives and their cost doesn’t deserve such callous carless handling by such misreprensentaions, and in general it also does much harm to reformation principals in general. John Knox is said to have described Puritanism as: Reformation without tarrying for any .” they needed no man to tell them how to live their lives as Christians, they needed purely and only the word of God to guide them.
The Puritans strangely were not all Calvinistic. The name itself has nothing to do with a doctrinal system or denomination. Many people would call Richard Baxter a confused Arminian, yet his labours and work lives on in his writings, and no one I know who speaks of him thinks of him as anything less than a great man of God despite his erroneous views on Justification-yet Calvinism today seems to be often used and held up very proudly as a badge of honour, as if just proclaiming oneself Calvinistic is all one needs to do to suggest oneself, as a superior stripe of Christian, yet even among professing Calvinists, much ignorant prevails, and it wouldn’t surprise me if the Calvinist denominations encourages more tares amongst the wheat than other denominations because of the pride associated with being one in very many cases. It seems likely that this will breed one sort of people who opt to profess outwardly with little to no inward or heart change that other less controversial and without the history attached to them that Calvinists have, other denominations wouldn’t have the same pulling power as they wouldn’t seem to have the same badge of honour to wear proudly as some so obviously do.. Those Puritans such as Richard Baxter who did have some unorthodox doctrinal beliefs, is still head and shoulders taller, then many who may have all their Calvinistic theological ducks all lined up in a row. Knowledge is one thing in our head, but only heart knowledge and heart change turns it into real knowledge of wisdom and understanding. Calvinism at it’s core should give no room for pride as by its very essence and nature it’s a doctrinal system of humiliation, that makes for humble and meek, men and women, and that is what the Puritans were, whether Calvinistic or not.
So, exactly who were these men and women we today call the Puritans?
T were purifying and reforming the whole of their lives; they were zealous for God and his glory at every turn; and in doing this they saw the planks in their own eyes, before seeing the failings and planks in others eyes.. The Scripture was the whole rule in life and practice. Where matters of worship were concerned, anything not commanded directly in Scripture was in their eyes forbidden, and practising anything outside of Scripture was nothing less than idolatry when it came to the act of worshipping God.
They aimed at piety in every aspect of their lives, not just in public, or in the pulpit, or when out and about, but in every aspect of their private lives. They believed the home should be made by the husband-and-wife into a family church. Yet, they were not austere or unloving quite the opposite is true. The husband as the head of the house, loved and nurtured and cared for his wife as Christ cares for his church. They were full of the love of God. They lived disciplined lives, everything was in moderation and with temperance, and only by being so, could it be to the glory of God. Whether eating, drinking, sleeping, recreation, everything was subordinate to the Scripture in carrying out these activities, so that they didn’t overindulge and their consciences remained clean. Keeping a clear conscience was of utmost import to the Puritans.
Their children were reared with great respect for their parents and taught the scriptures and the catachisms from very early ages. One one of the Puritans is said to have never spoken a word, never taken part in any activity, with his children, without talking a word of Christ to them also. Whether talking or wrestling with them, he still spoke of Christ to them.
The things that mattered to the Puritans, while often pass us by today, as we deem them insignificant and irrelevant, yet those issues are no less relevant to us in our day and age, may be in fact more relevant, because we live in a very different world to that of the Puritans and pilgrims, yet the word of the Lord is immutable and if something was right then, it cannot now be untrue for us without saying by implication that if it’s not true for us, then the Lord and his word is both changeable and not eternal and infinite-May it never be!
If you look through such books as Richard Baxter’s the Christian directory, you will see some of the questions that were on the minds and hearts of the Puritans
These are just a few of the subjects Baxter covered in his practical writings: Is anyone of these subjects NOT relevant to us today?
Chapter I: Directions to Unconverted, Graceless Sinners, For the Attainment of Saving Grace
Chapter II: Directions to Weak Christians for Their Establishment and Growth
Chapter III: The General Grand Directions for Walking with God, in a Life of Faith and Holiness: containing the Essentials of Godliness and Christianity
Chapter IV: Subordinate Directions Against the Great Sins Most Directly Contrary to Godliness
Chapter V: Further Subordinate Directions for the Next Great Duties of Religion; Necessary to the Right Peformance of the Grand Duties
Chapter VI: Directions for the Government of the Thoughts
Chapter VII: Directions for the Government of the Passions
Chapter VIII: Directions for the Government of the Senses
Chapter IX: Directions for the Government of the Tongue
Chapter X: Directions for the Government of the Body
Part II: Christian Economics
Chapter I: Directions about marriage; for choice and contract
Chapter II: Directions for the choice of 1. Servants, 2. Masters
Chapter III: Disputation, Whether the Solemn Worhsip of God in and by Families as such, Be of Divine Appointment
Chapter IV: General Directions for the Holy Government of Families
Chapter V: Special Motives to Persuade Men to the Holy Government of their Families
Chapter VI: Motives for a Holy and Careful Education of Children
Chapter VII: The Mutual Duties of Husbands and Wives Towards Each Other
Chapter VIII: Special Duties of Husbands to their Wives
Chapter IX: The Special Duties of Wives to Their Husbands
Chapter X: The Duties of Parents for Their Children
Chapter XI: The Duties of Children Towards Their Parents
Chapter XII: The Special Duties of Children and Youth Towards God
Chapter XIII: The Duties of Servants to Their Masters
Chapter XIV: The Duty of Masters Towards Their Servants
Chapter XV: The Duties of Children and Fellow-servants to One Another
Chapter XVI: Directions for Holy Conference of Fellow-servants and Others
Chapter XVII: Directions for every member of the Family
Chapter XVIII: Directions for the Holy Spending of the Lord’s Day in Families
Chapter XIX: Directions for Profitable Hearing God’s Word Preached
Chapter XX: Directions for Profitble Reading the Holy Scriptures
Chapter XXI: Directions for Reading Other Books
Chapter XXII: Directions for Right Teaching Children and Servants
Chapter XXIII: Directions for Prayers in General
Chapter XXIV: Directions for Families About the Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper
Chapter XXV: Directions for Fearful, Troubled Christians
Chapter XXVI: Directions for Declining, Backsliding Christians
Chapter XXVII: Directions for the Poor
Chapter XXVIII: Directions for the Rich
Chapter XXIX: Directions for the Aged and Weak
Chapter XXX: Directions for the Sick
Chapter XXXI: Directions to the Friends of the Sick
Part III: Christian Ecclesiastics
Chapter I: Of the Worship of God in General
Chapter II: Directions About the Manner of Worship
Chapter III: Directions About the Christian Covenant with God
Chapter IV: Directions About the Profession of our Religion
Chapter V: Directions About Vows and particular Covenants with God
Chapter VI: Directions to the People concerning Their Internal and Private Duty to Their Pastors
Chapter VII: Directions for the Discovery of Truth Among Contenders
Chapter VIII: Directions for the Union of Communion of Saints
Chapter IX: Twenty Directions how to Worship God
Chapter X: Directions about our Communion with Holy Souls Departed
Chapter XI: Directions about our Communion with the Holy Angels
Ecclesiastical Cases of Conscience
Part III: Christian Politics
Chapter I: General Directions for an Upright Life
Chapter II: General Directions for an Upright Life
Directions to subjects concerning their duty to rulers
Chapter IV: Directions to Lawyers about their Duty to God
Chapter V: The Duty of Physicians
Chapter VI: Directions to Schoolmasters
Chapter VII: Directions for Soldiers
VIII: Directions Against Murder
Chapter IX: Directions for the Forgiving of Injuries and Enemies
Chapter X: Cases Resolved about Forgiving Wrongs, Debts, and About Self Defence
Chapter XI: Special Directions to Escape the Guilt of Persecution
Chapter XII: Directions Against Scandal Given
Chapter XIII: Directions against Scandal Taken
Chapter XIV: Directions Against Soul-Murder
Chapter XV: General Directions for Furthering Salvation
Chapter XVI: Special Directions for Holy Conference, Exhortation, and Reproof
Chapter XVII: Directions for Keeping Peace with All Men
Chapter XVIII: Direcections Against all Theft, Fraud, or Injuries
Chapter XIX: General Directions and Particular cases of Conscience
Chaper XX: Motives and Directions against Opression
Chapter XXI: Cases and Directions about Prodigality and Sinful Waste
Chapter XXII: Cases and Directions against Injurious Lawsuits, Witnessing, and Judgment
Chapter XXIII: Cases of Conscience and Directions against Backbiting, Slandering, and Evil Speaking
Chapter XXIV: Cases of and Directions Against Censoriousness, and Sinful Judging
Chapter XXV: Cases and Directions About Trusts and Secrets
Chapter XXVI: Directions Against Selfishness
Chapter XXVII: Cases and Directions for Loving Our Neighbors as Our Selves
Chapter XXVIII: Cases of, and Directions for, the Love of Godly Persons
Chapter XXIX: Cases and Directions for Loving Enemies and Doing Them Good
Chapter XXX: Cases and Directions about Works of Charity
Chapter XXXI: Cases and Directions about Confesing Sins and Injuries to Others
Chapter XXXII: Cases and Directions about Satisfaction and Restitution
Chapter XXXIII: Cases and Directions about Our Obtaining Pardon from God
Chapter XXXIV: Cases and Directions About Self-Judging
And many more were covered in his mammoth work a Christian directory. You see, Baxter at heart, was a confused Arminian, in many ways, yet he was a Puritan and a force to be reckoned with, and his name has stood the test of time. Calvinism is a system of doctrine that I believe is true, and that I believe Baxter had some of it wrong. Yet the Christian life is about far more than doctrine, or theology, its about being living Bibles in the way we lives our lives, and the Word of the Lord coming first in every single thing we do every second that we are alive. Good doctrine is important of course, yet the Christian life is far more than that, and these men and women, the puritans, embodied what it should be.
Sometimes one hears the Puritans being referred to as Phariseecal, and considering they were all fallen men that has to be true in some cases just like its true of you and I , I daresay on some issues. Yet those who do say that should properly practise what the Puritans taught and practiced themselves first getting the plank out of their own eye, to let go of their pride, and to learn as those men and women did in much more dangerous times to do so than the most now, to put the word of the Lord above anything else, and that we are mostly just spiritual midgets compared with the puritans, and its often only another side of the same coin, of the pride that Calvinism today has attached to it, that makes us think we know better, when our lives and practices prove over and over again, that we don’t.
Filed under Uncategorized by Deejay




alt="Click here to join ReformersCorner">








Comments on The pride of modern Calvinism, the humililty of Puritanism »
lol. I never noticed the long, long sentence, but thank you for your comment Sarah!
I agree with you of course as far as “righteousness” I don’t think there is very little difference between the two words in this context, yet I think ‘Pious’ or ‘piety’ in our days gets a bad rap and has negative connations.
pi·e·ty Audio Help /ˈpaɪɪti/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[pahy-i-tee] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun, plural -ties.
1. reverence for God or devout fulfillment of religious obligations: a prayer full of piety.
2. the quality or state of being pious: saintly piety.
3. dutiful respect or regard for parents, homeland, etc.: filial piety.
4. a pious act, remark, belief, or the like: the pieties and sacrifices of an austere life.
[Origin: 1275–1325; ME piete < MF < L pietās, equiv. to pi(us) + -etās, var. (after i) of -itās; see pious, -ity]
—Synonyms 1. respect, veneration, awe. 2. godliness, devotion, devoutness, sanctity, holiness.
—Antonyms irreverence.
From: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/piety
[Reply]
First, let me be the first to tell you that I do believe that you out did Paul the Apostle with your run-on sentence! Excellent! ;o)
Second, I have to agree with you concerning those whose (all of us) pride and love is in the doctrine of Calvinism and not in the God of that doctrine which would naturally lead to the love of the doctrine but only secondarily. If I’ve said it once, I’ve said it twice…you can make a god out of anything! It is much easier to spout Calvinism than to live it out. This pride seems to be ramped and infectious on the Internet. People feel like they can hide behind their computers and spout off in a way they wouldn’t around those with whom they go to church. Sometimes I feel like I’ve entered the “Boys Club” when I go to some of these sites…the testosterone is thick! One read of the book “The Life of David Brainerd” could calm many of them God willing
I will have to disagree with you when you state “They aimed at piety in every aspect of their lives” and change piety to righteousness. Good post though!
[Reply]
Thanks,Sir HIcks!
Yeah I find blogs cofusing myself who have the comment boxes other than where I expect! (don’t do as I do, do as I tell ya!)
[Reply]
Great post, Deejay. (you should put the “leave a comment” thing at the END of your posts, though.
[Reply]